The internet home for David Notley 
MA MISM FTCL LTCL DipTchg

DISSERTATION - Chapter I - Case Study David Notley
     

Next

Previous

Dissertation

Glossary

Bibliography

Appendix 1

Home

 

The background to this chapter and the build up to my change in embouchure can be found in appendix 1.

In June of 1991 I was forced to stop playing for some eight months. I had my teeth rebuilt, 18 stitches in my lower lip, ribs and thumb broken, and a cracked jaw. This was due to a road traffic accident (see appendix 1)

Reading books and seeing diagrams about “How brass players do it” (by John Ridgeon) and thinking about my playing I had to make sure that I wouldn’t go back to my old ways of using pressure first. I started to practise buzzing first. This was difficult, as I, to this day, have no feeling in the front of my lower lip. I persevered and could buzz many tunes – the buzzing meant that I was able to control the pitch of my playing better and could move around the ranges easier. The buzzing meant also that all of my embouchure muscles were even and radiated out from the aperture.

I noticed that my upper teeth were a little long and came into contact with my lower lip also that my left lateral incisor tooth was twisted so I asked my dentist to file the edges down. My lower lip also had a stitch or thread added inside anchored at the top down to my chin.

 fig.1

fig.2  fig.3 fig.4 fig.5

  fig.6    fig.7


fig.8

I then had to think about my embouchure and why my aperture was closing when I went for higher notes. My aperture vibrated on the fleshy part of my top lip, back about two millimetres from where it was supposed to be. I had read that I was meant to “roll my lips in” to strengthen them and vibrate the aperture on the actual lip and not the fleshy part. My sound was more controlled and the control over my lips was greatly increased.

Previously when I vibrated my lips the Orbicularis Oris around my mouth had tightened unevenly, my top lip closed over my bottom lip. The Levator Labii Inferioris and Depressor Labii Inferioris pushed upwards from below and Depressor Alae Nasi pressed downwards from above. The Depressor Anguli Oris pulled downwards so that the muscles were pulling against each other.

One final observation of my previous embouchure was that the tongue would constantly be touching my bottom lip so articulation was problematical.

I had gained the embouchure through lack of knowledge and being told that there was no problem by teachers and that practice would “put everything right”. I sounded ok but I wanted to be better than OK. In my head I could hear what I wanted to do but my embouchure would do otherwise. I played trombone, French horn and euphonium for long periods but wanted to play the higher brass instruments.  

fig.9

My new embouchure was much different. The Obicularis oris rolled in evenly around my lips. The Depressor labii inferioris, Depressor anguli oris and Mentalis all pulled backwards easily. The Dilator and Compressor nasi of the nose and the facial muscles detailed above all pulled outwards.

When playing in the higher register these muscles pulled further outwards and gave the embouchure room to move. My Orbicularis palpebrarum around my eyes and the temporal fascia muscles around my ears also pull back.

Now I had control over my range and playing became a joy.

A quote from the great Herbert L. Clarke, the top soloist with the John Philip Sousa Band.from his autobiography “How I became a great cornetist”:

    “One day I picked up the instrument for the usual practice and imagine if you can my surprise and almost bewilderment when the first tone I produced with ease was the formidable high C! It was almost startling, but I tried it once more and for the second time produced this heretofore all but impossible tone. Now the whole secret was out, only there really wasn't any secret about it! I had used only a little pressure of the mouthpiece on my lips and so allowed them to vibrate naturally, instead of pressing against them with so great force that all lip vibration was stopped and tone would not come from the cornet. It then dawned upon my mind that, always when trying to reach a high note I had been pressing the mouthpiece so hard on the lips that it kept them from vibrating at all. I had been like a man trying to walk with his legs bound firmly together!”

Increasing my ability and being able to play what I heard in my head made me so much more confident. Although later two other problems surfaced whilst playing with Black Dyke:

1.      I developed in New Zealand a lung disease/ condition called Sarcoidosis, which affects the lungs and immune system. It is non-contagious but restricts breathing.

2.      My tonguing had been learnt with restriction on the space available in my mouth due to the position of my teeth. Double tonguing (ta-ka) and triple tonguing (ta-ta-ka) were easier but needed to happen at the back of my mouth instead of forward. This is now rectified but the schedule of such a great band meant that I could not devote the time to it then. My sound was too hard whilst multiple tonguing.

Next I needed to think about my tongue and breathing correctly. Knowing that my buzzing and whistling were regulated by the up and down movement of my tongue I experimented and after a short period was able to buzz long tunes.

The flow of air through the body to the instrument should be a smooth. Any obstacles should be removed. An open throat is needed for the air to flow through slowly for lower notes and lower dynamics. For louder and higher notes the airflow is accelerated. The channel for the air to travel through is narrowed depending on the range or dynamic required.

 
fig.10


fig.11

The above diagram shows the movement of the tongue through different vowel sounds, this is the same for both whistling and brass playing.

fig.12 fig.13

When playing in the upper range on my brass instrument the sides of my tongue – at the back of my mouth – push against my upper molar teeth (fig.13). This helps to create the smaller channel for my air to flow through faster, thus forcing the lips to vibrate faster.

When relaxed to play throughout the normal range of the instrument there is still a considerable amount of tension in my body. Firstly, in my embouchure and secondly in my diaphragm region. Pre-1991 I would have tensed my arms and pushed my mouthpiece against my teeth to gain increased range.

Now I buzz the notes and tense my stomach muscles downwards through my groin area all the way to my “backside” then past to my upper leg muscles – so as to “anchor” my body. This proves that the higher the pitch of the note, the greater the tension in the muscles.

 
     

 

Copyright © 2003 David Notley. All Rights Reserved.
Website created by Just Select Ltd